Originally constructed in 1870, the entire block burned to the ground in 1890. Construction on the current building was completed in 1895.
From it's beginnings with horse and buggy visitors through the introduction of automobiles, the Opera House was there and easily recognizable by the back of the stage sticking out over the sidewalk.
A typical winter day in front of the Opera House
After serving as an Opera House and Theater, the building has housed several markets and shops.
In the 1920s–1930s, many small-town opera houses like ours had transitioned from legitimate theater/opera to vaudeville and moving picture venues. A typical evening might include:
This mixed bill format kept audiences coming back in an era before television.

Hugh McVey was a specialty vaudeville act known for juggling and manipulative skills. He performed with Indian clubs (a popular juggling prop at the time, resembling bowling pins) and cane manipulation routines.
He seems to have been a working professional in the vaudeville circuit but not a major headliner (no widespread fame like some stars of the era). His ad in the 1895 Opera House during restoration suggests he likely performed there in the 1920s or 1930s as part of a mixed bill.
Hugh McVey was active in the early 1900s (mentions appear around 1900–1910s in entertainment trade papers like the New York Clipper). He was a professional specialty performer who toured circuits that included smaller venues.

John E. Flynn was an Irish dialect comedian, a very common genre in American vaudeville. Irish comedians often performed character sketches, monologues, songs, and patter with exaggerated accents, humor based on immigrant life, stereotypes (common at the time), and quick wit.
These kinds of acts were staples at Opera Houses turned into variety theaters — a juggler for visual appeal and an Irish comedian for laughs and relatability.
Flynn appears to have been a solid working comedian on the vaudeville circuit — not a national superstar, but the kind of reliable act that small-town opera houses like ours would book for a mixed bill.
A fire in between the Opera House and the Apartments directly behind it in the winter of 1949/1950 was almost a disaster, charred remains of the fire still exist upstairs on the balcony wall.
One of the fist things that was necessary to begin restoration was the removal of the building behind the Opera House which had unfortunately fallen into disrepair. Some of the damage from the 1949 fire is visible.

The property as purchased and ready for renovations. One side was an upholstery shop and the other was used for antique storage while the stage and seating area upstairs were converted to a haunted house for Halloween.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.